Showing posts with label bank of england. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bank of england. Show all posts

Monday, 19 April 2010

A Grilling for Mervyn King....

In my Money Week column this week, I've been wondering why Mervyn King doesn't get the same kind of grilling that Alan Greenspan gets in the US. Here's a taster....

There are few sights quite so grimly fascinating as watching a once stellar reputation come hurtling back down to earth. By the time he finally stepped down as chairman of the Federal Reserve Alan Greenspan was hailed as an economic mastermind. He was paid millions for a book, even more for speaking engagements. The markets continued to hand on the every word uttered by ‘the maestro’.
And yet last week, he was beaten up in Congress, castigated for his role in creating what now looks like one of the greatest bubbles of all time. Far from being a genius, Greenspan is rapidly being re-cast as the man who allowed a slow-motion train crash to play out on his watch, and did nothing to prevent it.
From a British perspective, however, it is interesting not just how the Greenspan story is being re-written, but how lightly his equivalents on this side of the Atlantic have so far escaped.
Shouldn’t Mervyn King, and indeed the Bank of England itself, come under the same kind for forensic examination? They certainly should. Plenty of different parties were to blame for the catastrophic build-up of British debts during the noughties, and the financial collapse that followed inevitably from it. But it is wrong that the Bank should evade accountability. After all, if we aren’t willing to learn from the mistakes of the past decade then we are condemned to repeat them.
Over in the US, there has been a lot more soul-searching over the central bank’s role in the build-up to the crash. Greenspan is still clinging on to his mantra that he was largely blameless. You can’t spot bubbles in advance, he still gamely insists. Even if you could, there wouldn’t be very much you could do about them. And, anyway, as he pointed out to Congress at last week’s hearing, there was a lot of pressure from politicians and others to expand lending, not curtail it. It’s not fair to blame him.
Maybe he’ll get away with that line. When the history books come to be written on the Great Crash of 2008, no doubt many different culprits will be fingered. But it is unlikely that Greenspan, with his policy of ultra-low interest rates, and of pumping up the economy during every minor downturn, will escape a hefty share of the blame.
But what about the Bank of England? Shouldn’t we be putting it under the microscope in the same way? So far, in this country we have pointed the finger everywhere other than the Bank’s Threadneedle Street headquarters. We have blamed the Americans, the bankers, the Financial Services Authority, and, of course, Gordon Brown. The Bank itself has skilfully managed to sidestep any real criticism.
That’s pretty odd. After all, the UK has suffered as badly as any country from the credit crunch. Our banking system collapsed as completely as any outside of Ireland. The bail-outs have been massive, saddling a whole generation with huge debts. Our economy has slumped into a longer recession than any other major economy.
It didn’t have to be like that. The other Anglo-Saxon economies didn’t suffer anything like so much. Australia is still booming – so much so that the central bank is steadily raising interest rates again. Canada didn’t see any significant banking crisis. In truth, the UK suffered so badly because of specific, home-grown policy mistakes.
It’s certainly fair to blame Gordon Brown. He over-regulated the economy, over-taxed it, and ran up too much debt. The FSA made a terrible mess of regulation: it concentrated on micro-managing who could open an account, whilst failing to notice that whole banks were going bust. And Britain was caught up in a worldwide financial storm as much as any other country.
And yet the Bank, surely, is guilty on two counts. It ran a loose monetary policy, allowing, if not actively encouraging, a runaway housing boom. And it did nothing to prevent the runaway build up of personal, corporate and government debt.
House prices have rocketed since the Bank was made independent in 1997. According to Nationwide data, in the thirteen years since then, the price of an average house in the UK has risen by 173%. True, the Bank’s Governor Mervyn King was one of the very few senior officials willing to warn publicly that the housing market was looking overheated. The Bank fretted about the housing bubble, and the impact it might be having on the economy. But it stopped well short of raising interest rates to choke it off.
Likewise, the UK built up extraordinary debts. According to McKinsey research, when you add together government, corporate and personal debt, the UK is now by far the most indebted of all the developed economies. Total debts are a staggering 450% of GDP. Most of that was built up in the last decade: total debt as a percentage of GDP roughly doubled since the Bank won its independence in 1997. Again, there are other culprits for that. The government borrowed a lot more than it should have done. Tax policy favoured debt over equity, stoking the boom in leveraged buy-outs. But you can’t exclude monetary policy. The interest rate is the price of debt. If people were taking out too much of the stuff – and in retrospect it is clear that they were – then surely it was priced too cheaply?
Both the housing boom and the debt bubble were fuelled by monetary policy that was too easy for too long. In the City, an independent Bank of England is viewed as a ‘good thing’, without any real debate. The fact remains that it has presided over a catastrophic collapse in the financial system.
In the US, they have started to rumble that the central bank might have had something to do with that. Here in Britain, we should at least be questioning whether ours did as well.

Saturday, 25 April 2009

Don't Bet On The Banks

In Money Week this week, I've been writing about the banks, and how despite the small recovery, they won't get vack to their old strenght. Here's a taster....

It has been a great couple of weeks for the global banking industry. Admittedly, it is coming off a low base, but after a year in which banks went bust, begging bowls for bail-outs were handed out, and bankers were pilloried for their greed and rapaciousness, there were at least some signs of health back in the financial system.
In the US, Goldman Sachs, always the class act of the industry, produced a terrific set of results. Morgan Stanley managed to do better than anyone in the market expected. And in this country, the stockmarket has started marking up the shares of the battered banks again.
Has the long-awaited bounce back in the banking industry started? In truth, probably not. Ignore the green shoots. Banking around the world remains a deeply troubled industry, and it is still going to be a very long time before it starts returning to a healthy level of profitability again.
Still, there is little mistaking the signs of recovery. If you were feeling optimistic, you might even be inclined to call them ‘green shoots’. In the US, Goldman Sachs posted earnings of $1.81 billion last week, easily besting even the most optimistic analysts’ forecasts. The old Wall Street rule that after a nuclear holocaust there would be only there things left alive – cockroaches, Keith Richards, and Goldman Sachs – appeared to be coming true again. Even the worst financial carnage in a generation turned into little more than a blip for the firm.
But it was far from alone. Wells Fargo last week posted record earnings for the period, as did JPMorgan Chase. Citigroup, perhaps the most bombed out of the major American banks, managed to end five consecutive quarters of losses by posting a profit of $1.6 billion. The American banks that survived the carnage looked to be clawing their way back towards health.
There are similar signs in Britain. We’re not yet seeing big bounce backs in profits. But the shares prices of our main banks are starting to anticipate better news down the track. Take Lloyds. From a low of 33p back in January, the shares have broken back through 100p. They jumped by a third last week alone.
Or Barclays. It said in March Barclays it had made a “strong start” to the year, and in February posted a 49 percent increase in profit for the second half of 2008. The sale of its iShares business has boosted its capital position. The shares have started to reflect that. From a low of 47p they are back above 200p.
Even Royal Bank of Scotland, now majority owned by the British taxpayer, is twitching back into life. From a low of 10p the shares are above 30p. It is a long way from recovery, but at least the corpse has been dragged out of the morgue.
True, fund managers have been seizing on any good news they can find. Everyone knew, even at the start of this year, that some kind of banking system would emerge from the crisis. Eventually it would be a profitable industry once more. At some point, there was always going to be a massive rebound in burnt-out share prices. Fund managers don’t want to miss out on that. They are making sure they are long on the shares wells before it happens.
There are positive signs. The worst of the credit crunch has passed. No more banks are likely to go bust – not big ones anyway. And there are reasons for thinking that profits may grow from here on. First, house prices are steadying, both in the US and UK. That will stem the flow of losses from sub-prime lending – and from a lot of commercial loans as well. Next, competition has been reduced, as anyone looking for a mortgage or a credit card will have noticed. Less competition means fatter margins, which is always good for profits.
Against that, however, there are three big issues overhanging the global banking industry.
One, there is still way too much capacity – they only reason competition has lessened is because of a shortage of funds. Banking looks set to become the auto or airline industry of the next decade. There are too many players making very similar products, but just as governments wouldn’t let their flag-carrier airlines go bust, and are still reluctant to let their car manufacturer go under, so they won’t let their banks go bust either. They will stagger on, over-staffed and barely profitable, until finally someone puts them out of their misery. Eventually there will four or five global mega-banks, and a host of niche players – but it will be a long time before we get there.
Two, banking is about to become zealously micro-regulated. There are already plenty of signs of that. In the US and the UK, Europe and even the offshore centre, financial supervisors are busy devising new rules and regulations. There will be caps on pay. There will be limits on lending. And there will be a clampdown on innovation. You’ve probably got more chance of getting a new type of cigarette advertised on children’s TV than you have of launching a clever new financial product right now.
Three, the best people are about to quit the industry. For a generation, banking attracted the most hard-working, ambitious, creative talent on the planet. Admittedly they devoted much of that brainpower to blowing the system up. Still, it made the industry dynamic. But a low-growth, micro-regulated industry isn’t going to attract anything but clock-watchers and pen-pushers – hardly a recipe for growth.
In reality, the banks will stabilize at some point. We may have reached bottom in January and started the bounce back. But it won’t be another boom in finance or banking – that is going to be the dullest of dull industries for a generation or more.

Wednesday, 25 March 2009

Another Step to Meltdown

The UK economy is taking a step closer to meltdown every day. The gilts auction failed today. It seems no one wants to buy British government debt yet. And we haven't even started issuing the stuff yet. Hang onto your hats.

Tuesday, 24 March 2009

The UK Takes A Step Closer to Meltdown

Although the chances of it are not more than 10% or 15%, there is a meltdonwn scenario for the UK. It is that inflation rises sharply, the currency collapses and the Bank of England has to hike interest rates sharply to control inflation. Then the economy would be in real trouble. It came a step closer today with the news that inflation roese despite the recession. Could it happen. Probably not. But it is a scary prospect, and even it doesn't, 1970s stag-flation is the best the UK can look forward to right now.

Sunday, 15 February 2009

Responsibility Moves Closer To Brown

Responsibility for the banking crisis is moving closer and closer to Gordon Brown all the time. The allegations of the HBOS whistle-blower Paul Moore may or may not stack up. In the end, it doesn't really matter. The facts are already quite clear. Brown created the regulatory system, and it clearly failed. At the very least, it now has to be admitted that the FSA is a failure, and responsibility for banking supervision needs to be handed back to the Bank of England. The UK has the worst banking crisis of the major world economies, and sooner or later Brown will have to own up to that.

Friday, 13 February 2009

The Banking Mess

Over on Comment Central today, there is a fascinating tidbit about how Mervyn King warned Gordon Brown and Tony Blair that it was a disaster to seperate out regulation of the banking system from the Bank of England. Brown, however, went ahead and created the FSA. And a disaster it has proved. Plenty of people warned about that at the time. You can't split central banking from supervision of the banking system, because, in a crisis, there are the same thing. As we deleve deeper into what looks like the worst recession of our lifetimes, the blame is going to shift more and more onto Brown - and of course on Ed Balls as well.

Monday, 2 February 2009

Reykjavik On The Thames

Britain isn't quite Iceland yet but it's economy looks in more and more trouble by the day. There has been a lot of glib talk about how the collapse in sterling will help out the British economy. But that ignores our reliance on imports. I noticed today that both Ford and Carlsberg said they were planning to raise their prices to take account of the fall in the value of sterling. We'll see a lot more of that in the year ahead. The net result is that inflatin will remain stubbornly high even as we move into a full-blown recession. One result will be to lower consumer spending even further, hitting demand. Another is that the Bank of England will have to think twice about lowering interest rates any furher. In a worse case scenario, it might even have to raise them. If that happened, the economy really would be plunged into a full-scale depression.

Friday, 23 January 2009

Banks, Banks and More Banks

I appear to have been either writing or talking about banks all week. On France 24 I took part in a pretty good discussion about the bonus culture, which you can see here. In the Spectator, I've been writing about the problems with the private banks. Over on Bloomberg, I've been looking at the run of mistakes and misjudgements that led to the collapse of Royal Bank of Scotland. From the Bloomberg column I got lots of response from former RBS bankers about just how badly the bank was run. My favorite was a story about how the head office in Edinburgh decided the receptionists around the world had to wear tartan uniforms, ignoring the fact that in countries like Singapore and Malaysia it was far too hot. That perfectly illustrates how little they understood the markets they were operating in.

Wednesday, 22 October 2008

The Pound Is Always Trouble For The UK

In my Bloomberg column I've been writing about the potential for a sterling collapse for some time. Indeed, I went off warning about it, because it never seemed to happen. Now, with the pound down to $1.62 from $2 in the space of a few weeks, it looks to be on the way. In Britain, an economic crisis is always in the end a sterling crisis, and this time around it looks no different. The UK econoy needs to be understood as a currency bubble, which is what has allowed the country to appear so prosperous. With that bursting, the trade deficit is going to be an issue again. So too is the fact that so much of government debt is funded overseas. Why would you want to buy that in a rapidly depreciating currency? There is a complacent assumption out there that so long as the Bank of England slashes interest rates, and the government pumps up spending, the economy will get through the downturn. But a collapsing currency puts real constraints on that, because it pushes up the cost of imports, and may make it impossible for the government to borrow more money.