Showing posts with label tax havens. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tax havens. Show all posts

Monday, 9 November 2009

Lay Off The Tax Havens

Everyone keeps attacking the tax havens. But there is very little evidence to suggest they played any role in the credit crunch, as I explain in my Money Week column this week. Here's a taster....

Which countries were most responsible for the financial crisis that engulfed the world last year? If you’ve been following the political debate over the last few months, you’d be forgiven for thinking it was a handful of secretive tax havens such as the Cayman Islands, Jersey, Switzerland or Monaco.
Everyone from President Obama to Nicolas Sarkozy of France to our own Prime Minister Gordon Brown has been queuing up to denounce the thriving offshore industry. Every G20 summit comes with a ritual denunciation of banking secrecy, and a fresh pledge to force open accounts. The suggestion is made that the huge fiscal deficits now being run up around the world could be plugged by clamping down on tax lost via offshore financial centres. Bullying tactics have been adopted against small countries to force them to change their laws in ways that suits their bigger and more powerful neighbours.
And yet two reports published in the last week showed that just about all the accusations hurled so furiously against the tax havens are just plain wrong. The British Treasury asked the accountants Deloitte to look into how much tax is lost through offshore loopholes. The answer? Not very much. Meanwhile, the left-wing Tax Justice Network, which campaigns ferociously against tax havens, has just published a report on the most secretive, un-cooperative financial centres in the world. The winner? Delaware, in the United States, closely followed by the City of London.
In truth, the attacks on tax havens are led by politicians guilty of presiding over precisely the system of secrecy they criticise elsewhere. What they are really frightened off is the way the havens provide an alternative to their own high-tax, big-spending policies.
It is certainly hard to escape the verbal hand grenades lobbed at the tax havens by the world’s leaders. In the US, Obama has launched a fierce crack-down on American companies using offshore subsidiaries for tax planning, pledging to raise tens of billions in extra revenue to plug his budget deficit. The Swiss banks have been forced to hand over the details of thousands of account holders. The French President promised to ‘put the morality back into capitalism’ by clamping down on the industry. The Germans have been bullying Lichtenstein into handing over details of account holders, whilst our own Gordon Brown promised “action against regulatory and tax havens in parts of the world which have escaped the regulatory attention they need.”
But how much tax is actually lost through the havens? And how secretive are they really? As it turns out, not nearly as much as people think.
The UK has always been in odd position on tax havens, because many of them – Jersey, the Isle of Man, Bermuda – are British crown dependencies. The Treasury has just published a report from Deloitte on their impact on the world financial system. The results were not quite what you might expect.
Written by Sir Michael Foot, a former director of the Bank of England, the report estimated that the amount of tax lost to the British government as a result of companies routing transactions through tax havens was less than £2 billon, far less than previous estimates suggested. In a country where the budget deficit looks set to breach the £200 billion barrier, that is little more than a rounding error – less than one percent of the shortfall in government revenues.
In exchange, the British banking system benefits from its relationship with the dependencies. They are used by the British banks to gather funds from around the world, which are then used to bolster the banks headquartered in London. So, for example, in a single quarter this year the dependencies provided almost £200 billion in net funds to the British banks. If the world was really to clamp down on tax havens the way Brown promises, the UK would be a net loser. It would collect only a tiny bit more tax. Against that, it would lose even more as the British banking system became less profitable – and so paid less corporation tax.
Nor does the secrecy charge have the weight you might imagine.
The Tax Justice Network’s ranking of the most secretive financial centres makes for surprising reading. Right at the very top of the list is Delaware, the US state routinely used by American corporations as their place of incorporation because of its pro-business legislation. Britain came in at fifth place, whilst Belgium and Ireland also featured in the top ten. Jersey didn’t make the top ten, nor Liechtenstein. Monaco was right down at the bottom of the list, ranking as one of the most open financial centres.
When you examine the evidence, it turns out the tax havens aren’t costing much in the way of lost tax. Nor are they particularly secretive.
There should be nothing in that, of course, to surprise anyone who actually knows how the financial system works.
In reality, the offshore centres are doing two things, both of them perfectly legitimate.
Fiscal systems around the world have become progressively more and more complex as governments attempt to squeeze impossible high amounts of tax out of the system. It is hardly a surprise that in an increasingly globalised world, companies choose to route their business through centres where taxes are simple, low and straightforward.
And they provide an alternative for people who object to paying the high rates of tax that governments in most of the developed world impose. People may or may not approve of that: but in a free world, it is surely an individual’s right to base themselves somewhere where half their income won’t be confiscated from them every year if that is what they want to do.
If they were really serious about cracking down on tax havens, Obama would be dealing with Delaware, and Brown would be hammering the City. And they would be a lot more honest about how their own policies have helped fuel their growth.
But then it is easier to launch attacks against scapegoats. And if they didn’t pretend they could raise more tax by plugging loop holes, they might have to start telling people how they planned to fix their deficits.

Saturday, 21 March 2009

Should Tax Havens Be Banned

In the run-up to the G20, there is lots of debate about tax havens. Everyone from Gordon Brown to Barack Obama is trying to ban them. There is a typcially thoughful piece by John Kay in the FT, and by my Bloomberg colleage Celestine Bohlen. My own view is that they are being picked on unfairly and made a scapehoat, a point I've been elaborating on in Moneyweek. Here's a taster....

Well, at least that is one thing cleared up. You might have imagined the credit crunch, and the sharp slowdown in the global economy, had something to do with the bursting of a credit bubble, lenders that ran out of control, and regulators and central bankers who turned out to be asleep at the wheel.
But no. It turns out it is all the fault of a few tiny state-lets such as Monaco, Liechtenstein and Andorra.
In the run up to the G20 summit to be held in Britain next month, prime ministers, chancellors and presidents have been launching blistering attack on the tax havens. “All jurisdictions must come within the rules,” the British Prime Minister Gordon Brown announced last week at a press conference in London with the German Chancellor Angela Merkel. “Standards that are being applied in some jurisdictions are too low. This is the beginning of the end of tax havens, and that is good news for everyone.”
The new U.S. President Barack Obama has set his sights just as squarely on the same target. He has promised to raise an additional $210 in taxes from American citizens and companies by cracking down the way money is pushed through offshore centres.
And there is plenty of evidence that the principalities and state-lets under attack are starting to buckle under the pressure. In the past month, Switzerland, Liechtenstein, Andorra and Monaco have all promised to change their banking laws. Territories such as Jersey and the Bahamas may not be far behind. Banking secrecy in the offshore industry is about to be consigned to history.
But hold on. There are two problems here. First, there is absolutely no evidence to suggest that the tax havens had any role in creating the financial crisis. And, in making them the scapegoat, we risk throwing away freedoms that we should all guard far more carefully.
Let’s start with the contention that offshore centres played a role in the credit crunch. So far, no one has been able to come up with a single shred of evidence to suggest why that might be so.
True, many of the sub-prime mortgages, off-balance sheet vehicles and derivatives contracts that played a role in the crisis may have been nominally offshore. But that is largely incidental. There is hardly a single complex deal struck anywhere in the world that doesn’t involve an offshore centre somewhere in the chain. It doesn’t follow that the use of tax havens created the crisis.
After all, the problems in the British banking industry were caused by lenders such as Northern Rock, Bradford & Bingley and HBOS completely abandoning prudent lending rules. It was buy-to-let mortgages in Leeds, and self-cert loans in Swansea, that caused the trouble – not debts run up by bankers in Jersey or brass-plate companies in the Cayman Islands. The problem was not that banks hid what they were doing. It was the regulators didn’t ask the right questions.
In reality, the politicians are playing two tricks with their attacks on the havens, both of them completely disreputable. They are creating a smokescreen designed to distract attention from the failures of the regulatory systems they created. And they are desperately looking for ways to shore up tax revenues that are starting to crumble as the recession bites.
There has been a long-running campaign to clamp down on tax havens. The Germans have led the way, with a series of bullying attacks on Liechtenstein, a favourite of wealthy Germans. Now Britain and the U.S., which are becoming high-tax countries as well, are joining the attacks.
And yet, the charges commonly levelled at the haven are entirely bogus.
For all the allegations about harbouring money launders and undermining global tax systems, we should remember that the havens in question, whilst they might not be full-blown nations, are sovereign entities. They are entitled to as much respect as any other small country.
So Germany, for example, has a perfect right to set whatever laws it likes for people living in Germany. If it wants to ban its citizens from holding accounts -- or setting up trusts and foundations -- in other countries, it can do so (and deal with the flight of people and capital that would certainly result). But it isn’t entitled to harass other countries into changing their laws – and neither is Britain or the U.S. If people want to put their money into a low-cost, low-tax country, that surely is their business.
There is no substance to the ludicrous charge, regularly peddled by campaigners against tax havens, that this is somehow ‘unfair’ tax competition. All competition is unfair. It is unfair that the Germans make terrific cars, causing all kinds of problems for everyone else’s auto industry. It is ‘unfair’ that the Italians make great suits, or the French terrific wine. Perhaps they should be stopped from doing that to make it easier for other countries. Absurd? Then why should Liechtenstein or Jersey be forced to close their financial-services industry?
Nor is there any evidence that they are used by money launders or terrorists any more than any other financial centre. Serious terrorists use everyday banks because they attract less attention. Third-world dictators will always find somewhere to park the odd billion.
In truth, the growth of the offshore industry has been driven by higher, more complex taxes in Europe and increasingly in the U.S. as well. Since becoming Chancellor more than a decade ago, Brown has turned one of the simplest tax systems in Europe into one of the most complicated. Obama is set on the same path in the U.S. Instead of picking on very small countries, Brown, Merkel and Obama would be better off using the G20 summit to start fixing their own.